Should I Buy a Used Lawn Mower? Yes, but check these first…


Who wouldn’t love a shiny new mower? The problem is many of the more capable models are seriously spendy, and at the end of the day, it is just a mower, right? To get our hands on a half-decent mower at an affordable price, we’ll need to be creative and put in some work to find a good used model.

There is a ton of mowers for sale out there; unfortunately, many of them are complete lemons with little to no serviceable life remaining. But if you know what you are looking for, you can, without a doubt, get a cracking deal. I’m a mechanic, and in this post, I’ll guide you through the whole process.

A used mower is worth buying so long as the mower deck is rust-free, the deck level adjusters work without binding, the self-drive system works without issue, the blade assembly is sound, and the engine runs well without smoking.

In this post, you’ll learn the pros and cons of a used mower; you’ll know where to locate great used mowers, how to check over a potential purchase, and how to care for your new mower.

Used mowers for sale

What Type Mower to Buy

Not all mowers are equal. A mower that doesn’t suit your yard or your ability won’t represent a wise purchase no matter how good the mower is or how reasonable the price was.

Mowers come in a few different flavors. In this section, we’ll look at the common mower types, their main features, and the type of yard work and users they are best suited to.

Electric Mower (corded)

The corded mower is a great solution for those with small level yards. The great thing about the electric mower is the ease of use. No gas or oil to check. It is literately plug in the long power cable and mow. Other advantages include easy to push, store clean, and requiring little maintenance.

Ideal for – Small yards, elderly users.

The downside – Ok, now for the downside. I can’t tell you how many cables I’ve replaced in the workshop. Cutting the cable is a common own goal occurrence. Replacing the cable isn’t expensive apart from feeling a little silly. There’s no actual harm done.

Battery Powered (cordless)

The natural progression of the corded mower is the cordless or battery-powered mower, and it is a great success. There is lots to love about the battery-powered mower, including ease of use, no maintenance, no gas, oil, etc., to store.

My father was elderly and last season. I replaced his gas mower with a battery model. Sure he complained at first, who liked change, but I could see pulling on the cord was becoming a real strain.

One season on, he loves it.

Battery-powered mowers are great for small to medium size lawns, but various size batteries and additional batteries are available, quick to swap out, and interchangeable with other home power tools.

Ideal for – small to medium yards, elderly users.

The downside – Not much. Batteries are the latest tech lithium-ion. They won’t last forever and are expensive to replace.

Gas Powered Walk Behind – Push Mower

The walk-behind gas-powered push mower is the entry-level gas-powered mower. Gas power brings some significant power advantages and, of course, the ability to cut grass all day long. The entry-level mower typically has small engines and is not driven, meaning they only move if the user pushes it along.

Ideal for – Medium size flat yards with heavier grass types.

Downside – Gas engines require maintenance and careful winter storage, storing gas and oil on-site and can be heavy to push.

Gas Powered Walk Behind – Self Propelled Mower

This is, as you’ve guessed, a gas-powered mower with a powered drive system (known as a self-propelled or self-drive mower) and that makes them the most desirable and ubiquitous model. The great advantage is, of course, the ease of use. The self-drive means the operator needs only to guide and turn the mower. It is, as you can imagine, excellent for more extensive laws with lots of open spaces.

Self-propelled (rear-drive) – Rear-drive is excellent for hilly yards.

Self-propelled (front-drive) – Front-drive is excellent for yards with many obstacles.

Mulching Mower

A mulching mower is designed to clip the grass very finely and disperse those clippings evenly on the lawn. The advantages include a well-fed lawn, saves on bagging and collecting labor, and is environmentally friendly.

Ideal for – large lawns that are unused

Downside – A mulched lawn initially appears a bit brown until clippings decompose. Walking on a mulched lawn leaves clippings on your footwear and so not ideal for young families.

Three in One Mower

The 3 in 1 mower does it all. It mulches, throws, and collects (bags). Fitted to top-end mowers and usually requires either fitting a plastic block to the deck or sliding a lever to engage the mulching feature.

Ideal for – Great for extensive laws with all types of terrain.

Downside – It’s a more complex mower, and they are more expensive to maintain.

Robot Mower

Robot mowers are the latest advancement in mowers. Although they have been on the market for many years, the latest models are becoming less expensive and offer an ever-increasing number of features as standard.

Ideal for – Great for those who dislike cutting grass and love the idea of automating the whole process,

Downside – Although they are reliable, when they fall over, they are expensive to maintain. They are tech-heavy, and if you don’t like technology, you’ll dislike the robotic mower.

Riding Mowers aka Tractor Mowers

I don’t cover riding mowers here as I covered it previously, and you can check out my tractor buying post here “Should I buy a used Riding mower?”

Advantages of Buying Used Mower

  • Usually strike a great deal with the owner
  • Talk directly to previous owner
  • Test mower before buying
  • Get to see the environment in which the mower lived and worked

Disadvantages of Buying Used Mower

Here’s a helpful list of the downside of buying a used mower. Not all of these apply to all mowers.

  • Selecting and buying a suitable used mower is time consuming
  • Buying a mower is risky
  • Transporting the mower is a pain
  • Used mower don’t come with warranty

Where to Buy a Used Mower

The very best place to buy a used mower is a garage sale. That way, you get to talk to the owner directly, and most owners are honest and are only too happy to tell anything you want to know about their mower.

Local online marts, Facebook market, etc., but bear in mind mowers are likely not worth driving too far to collect, besides, mowers are so ubiquitous you won’t have trouble finding a suitable example locally.

What to Look For and How to Check a Used Mower

Folks sell mowers for all types of reasons, usually because the mower doesn’t start and it’s got a few years on it. The owner wages it’s better to cut their losses and just buy a new one. These type mowers usually offer the very best value, as most non starting mowers require little more than a carburetor cleaning and fresh gas. No parts, just some elbow grease, and a tune-up.

Anyhow here’s my used mower pre-purchase checklist:

  • Check engine brand (see below)
  • Check the engine oil level and quality – low oil level, very black, thin or grey oil is a bad sign
  • Check for leaks – engine oil or gas leaks will leave obvious witness marks
  • Open gas cap and check gas – old gas turns yellow and smells stale, it’s the most common cause of no starts
  • Check deck corrosion – some rust is ok, but holes isn’t

Turn mower over on its side carburetor side up

Place mower back on it wheels again

  • Check pull start by attempting to start the engine – pull cord should pull mover over without recoiling sharply. If it does it’s a sure sign of a damaged engine
  • Check drive – apply the drive bail lever and pull the mower rear wards, the rear wheels should lock. Free wheeling suggest drive needs adjusting or is faulty

If the engine starts, check the following:

If a used mower passes most of these tests it’s a good mower and worth buying.

Best Mower Brands

Here are my favorite mower brands, while none of them are perfect they are honest mowers and parts aren’t expensive.

  • Honda mowers
  • Husqvarna
  • Craftsman
  • Toro
  • Troy-bilt
  • Cub Cadet
  • John Deere

Mower Engine Makers

Most mowers makers don’t actually build their own engines. Instead, they fit a third-party engine. When considering a used mower, make sure it has one of the following engine brands fitted. The reason is simple, these engines all tried and tested. In addition, parts are easily available and repair shops are familiar with them.

  • Briggs & Stratton
  • Kohler engines
  • Kawasaki engines
  • Honda engines
Blower assembly

Briggs & Stratton engine

Kohler engine

Honda engine

Honda engine

How Much to Pay For Used Mower

A used mower that requires little in the way of repairs is likely worth up to half the price of its brand new equivalent. You can move that price lower the older the mower is.

Will a Used Mower Fit in a Trunk?

Mower in a field

Most medium-size mowers will fit in the trunk of a family-size car. A hatchback will obviously be your best option save maybe a pickup.

Most modern mowers are equipped with a toolless handlebar release which allows the operator to fold the handlebars flat across the body of the mower.

This is usually all that’s required to fit a mower into the average family hatchback or sedan. That said here are a few additional transportation tips:

Check out the video repair section for more details on these and many other repair tips.

You may find the following posts helpful:

Mower blowing white smoke

Turn gas tap off

How long does the Toro mower last?

Should I buy a used lawn tractor?

Should I buy a used power washer?

John Cunningham

John Cunningham is an Automotive Technician and writer on Lawnmowerfixed.com. I've been a mechanic for over twenty-five years, I use my knowledge and experience to write fluff-free "How to" articles that help homeowners fix lawnmowers, tractor mowers, chainsaws, leaf blowers, power washers, generators, snowblowers ...

Recent Posts